How are experiences of justice treatment interdependent with justice outcomes and decisions? What evidence is there to suggest that both victims, accused and defenders care about the overall rights and fairness of processes, challenging zero-sum game models?

Background

The Scottish Government’s Vision for Justice aims to establish an effective, modern person-centred and trauma-informed approach to justice in which everyone can have trust, including as victims, those accused of crimes and as individuals in civil disputes. As such, Justice Analytical Services have identified the theme of ‘Justice Processes & Experiences’ as a research priority. Robust research on justice processes, the experiences of complainers and the accused as well as the functioning of juries will inform work towards this aim.

Next steps

Get in touch with [email protected]

Source

This question was published as part of the set of ARIs in this document:

Justice analytical services areas research interest

Research fields

No research fields assigned yet

Related UKRI funded projects


  • Victims' access to justice through English criminal courts, 1675 to the present

    This interdisciplinary project examines public access to justice in England over three centuries - from the 1670s to the present. Bringing together leading criminologists and crime historians, it will assemble and analys...

    Funded by: ESRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Essex

    Why might this be relevant?

    This project focuses on victims' access to justice in England over three centuries, providing insights into the relationship between victims and offenders, access to legal resources, and changes in victim participation over time.

  • Victims of crime, criminal justice and social exclusion

    I will use my institutional and AHRC leave to complete a book project, 'Victims of Crime, Social Exclusion and Criminal Justice'. This book will be a socio-legal analysis of the rights of victims of crime in the UK crimi...

    Funded by: AHRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Manchester

    Why might this be relevant?

    This project analyzes the rights of victims of crime in the UK criminal justice system, examining victim policy inclusivity, responsibilization strategies, and the impact on victims and accused.

  • Psychological changes expected and experienced by victims who communicate with offenders

    There is evidence that some victims of crime benefit from communication with offenders, at least some of the time, but little is known about how these benefits occur. Many have theorised about the mechanisms by which res...

    Funded by: ESRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Oxford

    Why might this be relevant?

    Partially relevant as it focuses on psychological changes in victims communicating with offenders, but does not directly address justice treatment interdependence.

  • Justice, Inequality and Gender Based Violence

    The proposed research will address the knowledge gap that exists regarding justice, inequality and gender based violence (GBV). The aim is to address how 'justice' (in its wider sense) is understood, sought, and experien...

    Funded by: ESRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Bristol

  • Everyday Challenges to the Rule of Law: The Case of Civil/Criminal Procedural Hybrids

    Rules of legal procedure determine the steps to be taken and standards to be met in the resolution of issues coming before the law. Due to their different purposes - criminal law being to punish, civil law to compensate ...

    Funded by: AHRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Leeds

    Why might this be relevant?

    Partially relevant as it focuses on civil/criminal procedural hybrids, which may not fully address the broader question of justice treatment interdependence.

  • Language of DIY Justice: Communication practices & processes

    The project explores the language of DIY Justice by focusing on communication as an inherent part of court hearings as well as court processes and procedures. Since cuts to legal aid in 2013, an increasingly high number ...

    Funded by: AHRC

    Lead research organisation: Birmingham City University