What impact has greater use of pre-recorded evidence had on the administration and delivery of justice in Scotland and on criminal justice partners more generally?

Background

The Scottish Government’s Vision for Justice aims to establish an effective, modern person-centred and trauma-informed approach to justice in which everyone can have trust, including as victims, those accused of crimes and as individuals in civil disputes. As such, Justice Analytical Services have identified the theme of ‘Justice Processes & Experiences’ as a research priority. Robust research on justice processes, the experiences of complainers and the accused as well as the functioning of juries will inform work towards this aim.

Next steps

Get in touch with [email protected]

Source

This question was published as part of the set of ARIs in this document:

Justice analytical services areas research interest

Research fields

No research fields assigned yet

Related UKRI funded projects


  • UK-Brazil Eyewitness Memory Network

    The aim of this project is to launch the UK-Brazil Eyewitness Memory Network, which will be formed by prominent researchers in the field of eyewitness testimony from both countries. Eyewitness testimony is crucial in var...

    Funded by: ISPF

    Lead research organisation: University of Portsmouth

    Why might this be relevant?

    The project focuses on eyewitness testimony in criminal justice systems, which is related to the administration and delivery of justice in Scotland.

  • Promoting justice: Professionalising frontline policing with an evidence-based Structured Interview Protocol

    Evidence obtained from victims and witnesses is of critical importance to the criminal justice system. Current interview procedures for eliciting this evidence frequently fall short of best practice, and have not kept pa...

    Funded by: ESRC

    Lead research organisation: Goldsmiths, University of London

    Why might this be relevant?

    The project focuses on improving investigative interview procedures to elicit high-quality evidence, which directly impacts the administration and delivery of justice in Scotland.

  • Putting Cognitive Science to Work in the Legal System: An Evidence Based Approach to Testimony Evaluation and Beyond

    This programme of research will focus on using methods from law, psychology, and neuroscience to examine how the credibility, accuracy, and overall reliability of eye-witness accounts are assessed in the criminal justice...

    Funded by: UKRI FLF

    Lead research organisation: UNIVERSITY OF EXETER

    Why might this be relevant?

    The project examines how credibility and reliability of eye-witness accounts are assessed in the criminal justice system, directly related to the impact of pre-recorded evidence on justice delivery.

  • Prosecutors' Interviews with Crown Witnesses: A Socio-Legal and Comparative Analysis

    Prosecution barristers traditionally do not speak to complainants and other prosecution witnesses in England and Wales. Fears of being accused of 'coaching' a witness to testify at trial have precluded virtually all dire...

    Funded by: AHRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Nottingham

    Why might this be relevant?

    The project evaluates the benefits and risks of pre-trial witness interviewing, directly addressing the impact of greater use of pre-recorded evidence on justice delivery in Scotland.

  • Putting Cognitive Science to Work in the Legal System: An Evidence-Based Approach to Testimony Evaluation and Beyond (Renewal)

    My FLF project involves a systematic and interdisciplinary line of research drawing on techniques from across fields to examine and improve testimony evaluation in the justice system, and to promote the effective integra...

    Funded by: UKRI FLF

    Lead research organisation: UNIVERSITY OF EXETER

    Why might this be relevant?

    The project focuses on testimony evaluation in the legal system, which is directly related to the impact of pre-recorded evidence on justice delivery.

  • Victims' access to justice through English criminal courts, 1675 to the present

    This interdisciplinary project examines public access to justice in England over three centuries - from the 1670s to the present. Bringing together leading criminologists and crime historians, it will assemble and analys...

    Funded by: ESRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Essex

  • Everyday Challenges to the Rule of Law: The Case of Civil/Criminal Procedural Hybrids

    Rules of legal procedure determine the steps to be taken and standards to be met in the resolution of issues coming before the law. Due to their different purposes - criminal law being to punish, civil law to compensate ...

    Funded by: AHRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Leeds

    Why might this be relevant?

    The project addresses the blurring of civil and criminal procedures, which is related to the broader theme of justice processes and experiences.

  • Special Measures for Vulnerable Witnesses: Use, Effectiveness, and Improvement

    The use of special measures (i.e., provisions introduced by the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act, 1999) to support vulnerable witnesses giving evidence in court has recently increased dramatically. Best-practice u...

    Funded by: ESRC

    Lead research organisation: Keele University

  • Harnessing metacognition to assess the accuracy of memory reports from children in the Criminal Justice System

    Each year, millions of child witnesses, from as young as 2 years old, provide evidence based on their memory of events in Criminal Justice Systems around the world. Child witnesses, including victims, are increasingly be...

    Funded by: ESRC

    Lead research organisation: University of Birmingham

  • Towards the development of a framework for the interviewing of vulnerable people by the police in Japan

    This application develops research collaboration between researchers and police officers, both in Japan and the UK, to identify, for the first time, the framework for a best practice model for the interviewing of vulnera...

    Funded by: FIC

    Lead research organisation: De Montfort University